Showing posts with label Keynesian economics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Keynesian economics. Show all posts

Saturday, January 5, 2013

A Cash for Clunkers update




.


Back in 2009, the Cash for Clunkers program was envisioned as a $3 billion tax-payer funded boost to the economy by offering a $4,500 rebate on used cars to be applied towards a new one. The thought was that this stimulus program would aid a flagging auto industry, bump economic activity and get older less-fuel efficient cars off the street and thus, out of the environment.

Turns out none of this happened as hoped for. As we’ve chronicled in previous posts, Cash for Clunkers has resulted in Clunker’s remorse for people who jumped on the $4,500 rebate and found themselves in a 5-year new car lease that, as it turns out, they could not afford (and the housing/financial crisis was all Wall St.’s fault?) and for a car that a year later they no longer wanted.

Cash for Clunkers also shafted lower/working class families out of perfectly serviceable used cars that they could have employed to get to and from work, school, the market, the doctor, etc. By taking 690,000 used cars out of circulation, it bumped up the price of used cars further putting those cars out of the reach of affordability for those who needed it the most. With transportation mobility comes upward economic mobility and Cash for Clunkers did its part in snuffing out that dream for many lower-income American families.

Cash for Clunkers also shafted charities out of used cars that would’ve been otherwise turned over to them for refurbishment and then turned back over to that charity’s targeted need.

And, as studies have shown, Cash for Clunkers was merely “sugar” as it did temporarily spike auto sales but all it was doing was stealing demand from later on down the road. Overall, net car sales remained flat.



Now, as it turns out, Cash for Clunkers, on top of everything else was/is, horrible for the environment as well.


According to E Magazine, the “Clunkers” program, which is officially known as the Car Allowance Rebates System (CARS), produced tons of unnecessary waste while doing little to curb greenhouse gas emissions.

The program's first mistake seems to have been its focus on car shredding, instead of car recycling. With 690,000 vehicles traded in, that's a pretty big mistake.
According to the Automotive Recyclers Association (ARA), automobiles are almost completely recyclable, down to their engine oil and brake fluid. But many of the “Cash for Clunkers” cars were never sent to recycling facilities. The agency reports that the cars’ engines were instead destroyed by federal mandate, in order to prevent dealers from illicitly reselling the vehicles later.

The remaining parts of each car could then be put up for auction, but program guidelines also required that after 180 days, no matter how much of the car was left, the parts woud be sent to a junkyard and shredded.

Shredding vehicles results in its own environmental nightmare. For each ton of metal produced by a shredding facility, roughly 500 pounds of “shredding residue” is also produced, which includes polyurethane foams, metal oxides, glass and dirt. All totaled, about 4.5 million tons of that residue is already produced on average every year. Where does it go? Right into a landfill.

E Magazine states recycling just the plastic and metal alone from the CARS scraps would have saved 24 million barrels of oil. While some of the “Clunkers” were truly old, many of the almost 700,000 cars were still in perfectly good condition. In fact, many that qualified for the program were relatively “young,” with fuel efficiencies that rivaled newer cars.

And though the point was to get less fuel efficient cars off the roads, with only 690,000 traded in, and over 250 million registered in the U.S., the difference in pollutant levels seems pretty negligible.

But all that vehicular destruction did more than create unnecessary waste for the environment. It also had some far-reaching economic effects.




Fully 60% of a car’s recyclable value is in its engine and drivetrain but by federal mandate, the car’s engine was to be filled with a sodium silicate solution and left to rust away in perpetuity in a landfill near you.

Because it was a brief program and because it had a limited scope, Cash for Clunkers, of all the Keynesian gimmickry employed by the federal government, provides perhaps the clearest and best example of the negative consequences that result from the government injecting itself into the marketplace.

Cash for Clunkers: no net positive effect on auto sales, a bain to this country’s charities, sticking it to lower-income families and, now, horrible for the environment. What’s not to love about all that?


.


Wednesday, June 20, 2012

What were we tweeting about today?





.

Second day in a row. A trend? Uh-oh.



Saw the following headline and the lede paragraphs below it from The Hill today:


HHS touts health law for creating jobs, expanding care


Federal health officials announced that new grants under the the healthcare reform law will expand clinic access to more than 1.25 million Americans and create roughly 5,640 jobs.

The grants were awarded Wednesday to 219 local health centers. They are worth $128.6 million, according to the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS).


Tweet: By this logic, not taking care of yourself and making crappy lifestyle choices will be great for the economy.



It just never appears to sink in withy the statist/Keynesian set that government spending does not "create" jobs. Spending in this manner is merely a wealth transfer. As we noted in the previous post, however, old habits don't die hard they just don't die.


Follow us on Twitter: @deanriehm

.

Don't expect a change any time soon


.

When the President signed into law the National Defense Authorization Act back in November of last year granting himself the power to indefinetely detain U.S. citizens here on American soil without cause, we're wondering if he had this lady in mind.

Sheryl Attkisson of CBS News has been one of the few members of the legacy media to cover Fast and Furious and now she will continue to be a thorn in the side of the administration as she gets into the failed and corrupt Department of Energy green energy loan program.


A123 Systems builds batteries for electric cars and they spent $1 million in lobbying efforts and for their trouble they received $249 million in federal stimulus funding. This allowed them to employ 1,000 people to make these batteries - one small problem, however, the batteries don't work.



Here's Attkisson's report:






Oh goody. They've still got $100 million of our money to blow through on a product/technology for which they did not receive the original grant money. Considering their success with the battery, what could possibly go wrong?


And as for the Fisker, perhaps the slow demand, aside from the fact that it doesn't work is due to the fact that the two models being produced (in Finland... with over $500 million of our money, no less) cost $97,000 and $57,400 a copy and, unfortunately, we currently have a shortage of rich, smug liberals.


As the subject of this post, suggests, no amount of these embarrassing failures are going to dissuade these rigid ideological extremists from behaving any diffently.


H/T: Hot Air


.












Friday, January 27, 2012

Economic illiteracy re-visited

.

Andrew Napolitano and his panel on "Freedom Watch" take on the Davos Dodos of the ski party, one in the same that we did here, and yet another round of Keynesian gimmickry to keep people who are underwater in their homes still further forestalling a true housing recovery.





"It's kind of grotesque that the government is coming in and abrogating privity of contract."


And even more grotesque when you can say it with an indignant British accent.



If compelling banks to write down home loans sounds familiar, it should, as we have been down this road before back at the beginning of the Obama administation in January of 2009.

With the help of Martin Scorcese, no less, here is what we wrote about it at the time which illustrated not only the non-sensicalness of it but more importantly, the moral hazards inherent to the cozy private-public relationships in Bailout Nation:




From the Wall St. Journal:

A Senate bill aimed at giving strapped homeowners more leverage in renegotiating their mortgages cleared a hurdle Thursday when Citigroup Inc. dropped its opposition.

The legislation, which is being advanced by top Senate Democrats, would let judges set new repayment terms for mortgage holders in bankruptcy court. Lawmakers say the measure is aimed at jump-starting broader efforts to renegotiate millions of underwater mortgages now weighing down the housing market.


To better help illustrate what you just read, we call in Academy Award-winning director Martin Scorcese and his outstanding movie Good Fellas. In this scene, a restaurant owner needs some financial help and needs some protection from the cops, other wise guys, people who don’t pay their bills, etc., so he goes to the local crime boss and talks him into going in as partners. Great. The restaurant owner is now partnering up with the local muscle. Good times, right? What could possibly go wrong?

In this clip, Citigroup is the restaurant owner and “Paulie” is the Federal Government.





Wow. That didn’t end too well, now did it?

Maybe now, you are beginning to get an idea of why this bailout business was such a bad idea from the get-go. We’re not Wall St. experts but perhaps the reason why Citigroup dropped its opposition to this legislation is because “Paulie” is into them for $45 billion.



Until recently, Citigroup had fiercely opposed proposals to give bankruptcy judges latitude to change the terms of mortgages. Its about-face comes after the federal government has pumped $45 billion into the company since last fall. The government is now keeping the company on a tight leash.



Just. like. that.

Let that last line linger for a moment. Taste it again. Let it roll over your palate like vinegar.

Citigroup danced with the devil and lost. They never had a chance. Now that they are the Feds’ lap dog and a newly-minted GSE, any hopes they had of exercising any independent decision-making pretty much just blew right out the window.

And that money that the lenders will be losing with the “restructured” loans will have to made up from somewhere, right? But, where? The first logical place would be to charge higher interest rates for new home loans… but if those higher interest rates are not competitive then Citigroup cannot offer their money for these loans which could then ultimately lead to… if you were going to complete this sentence with “bankruptcy”, you haven’t been paying attention… even more of your tax dollars going to pay for other people’s home loans.

The lynchpin of free enterprise and capitalism: the contract – a contract between two independent entities spelling out the terms for an exchange of goods, services, money and which is bound by law is about to become a thing of the past.
In its place, a capricious set of variables set forth by some who are on the take from the very people they are overseeing and and who are dispensing this power in an arbitrary fashion as they see fit. (ed. note: remember what the British chap said about grotesquness)

We hope we are being guilty of hyperbole, but of all the ridiculous non-sense we have seen and heard with respect to Bailout Nation, this was the first instance that sent shivers down our spine. We welcome cheerful thoughts and comments.



3 years on and nothing has been learned. 3 years on and it's all still business as usual.


.

Friday, January 20, 2012

So, what was all that about, again?




.

In the news today:


Americans are holding onto cars and trucks longer, pushing the average age of a vehicle to a record 10.8 years.

The Polk research firm said Tuesday that the average age of a car last July was 11.1 years, while the truck average was 10.4.

Unemployment and the sour economy have caused people to put off buying cars and trucks.


And $3 billion poured down the drain of Keynesian gimmickry ain't gonna change any of that.

Saturday, December 24, 2011

New York Times doing it's best to push jobs stimulus on 19th century technology




.

Because AmTrak has been such a huge success over the years.


Slow-speed choo-choos!





Water flows uphill.

A city turns down $8.5 million in federal grant money.

In what could be a new high water mark of anti-Washington sentiment, the city of Troy, Mich., is rejecting a long-planned transportation center whose construction would have been fully financed with federal stimulus money.

The terminal, which would help Troy become a transportation node on an upgraded Detroit-to-Chicago Amtrak line, was hailed by supporters as a way to create jobs and to spur economic development. But federal money is federal money, so with the urging of the new mayor, who helped found the local Tea Party chapter, the City Council cast a 4-to-3 vote this week against granting a crucial contract, sending the project into limbo.

“There’s nothing free about government money,” Mayor Janice Daniels said in an interview. “It’s never free, and it’s crippling our way of life.”

Other Republican officeholders have said “Thanks, but no thanks” to federal money for high-speed rail: Gov. Scott Walker of Wisconsin rejected an $810 million federal grant to extend passenger rail from Milwaukee to Madison; Gov. Chris Christie of New Jersey killed a project to dig a new commuter rail tunnel under the Hudson River. But those actions have generally involved criticism of the underlying logic of the projects, or projections of enormous costs to be borne down the line by state and local governments.

The Troy transit center’s construction, by comparison, required no local contribution, and its predicted annual maintenance cost of $31,000 was, in the context of the city’s $50 million budget, “de minimis,” said Mark Miller, the assistant city manager.

The federal government’s largess is no reason to build the transit center when the national debt stands at $15 trillion, Mayor Daniels said.

Yet if the money does not go to Troy, it will not be used to pay down the national debt; it will be redirected to other projects around the country.

Taking Tea Party reasoning to the local level has outraged supporters of the transit center, which has been in the works for a decade. Michele Hodges, the president of the Troy Chamber of Commerce, which supports the transit project, said that her organization “will be a pit bull for what’s best for this community.”

David A. Kotwicki, a local lawyer, noted that members of Congress might talk tough on spending, but that they still bring projects home to their districts. The vote against the transit center, he said, looks like “cutting off your nose to spite your face.”

.

A few things jumped out at us while reading this: a) the general snotty tone with respect to what they perceive as tea party logic rejecting all money merely because it comes from Washington D.C. b) the author never makes the case for the long-term viability of the transportation center... nor does it make the case for the most obvious question: is this transportation center even needed? c) appears to champion taking federal money merely on the grounds that it will just go to another pork barrel project elsewhere and not pay down the national debt if rejected.


The over-arching logic employed by the Times in this article is precisely the logic that has made us the brokest nation on the planet. To the Times, pork is a fungible asset and just the natural order of things so you might as well take advantage of it.

Taking a principled stand against further dependence on the federal government and stemming the tide against the Keynesian make-work philosophy of the statist political class in our counrty is, however, something that is derided in the pages of the New York Times.

Thursday, November 3, 2011

Cash for Clunkers: the gift that keeps on giving




At the height of the Keynesian gimmick known as Cash for Clunkers, we noted that charities weren't too hot on the idea as the program succeeded in taking older, lower gas mileage, but certainly serviceable cars off the market. The very types of cars favored by lower-income folks to get back and forth to work.

It appears now that we are discovering one of the legacies of Cash for Clunkers.


For more than a century, efforts to help the disadvantaged have focused on education, healthcare, nutrition and housing. Almost nothing has been done to help the working poor afford cars, despite research that indicates it would help alleviate poverty.

About 1 in 4 needy U.S. families do not have a car, according to the Annie E. Casey Foundation. That's a serious handicap for the millions of Americans who don't have access to robust mass transit.

A nationwide survey of 353 people who bought cars with help from a nonprofit group called Ways to Work found that 72% reported an increase in income. Of those who were on public assistance when they acquired a car, 87% were no longer receiving it a few years later.

Other studies have found that low-income people were more involved in community activities and had better access to healthcare after getting cars, while their children participated more frequently in after-school programs.

"You're more likely to have a job and less likely to be fired," said Evelyn Blumenberg, a professor of urban planning at UCLA who studies transportation and poverty. "It's just a no-brainer that low-income families need cars."

Yet there are almost no state or federal programs to meet the need.
(italics, ours)

Let that last sentence sink in. Cash for Clunkers destroyed 700,000 cars. You don't think that a good chunk of that 700,000 cars, were they still around, could be meeting the needs of the poor and low income families in this country?

There was a federal program, alright. But it was a federal program that absolutely shafted people who need wheels to get to work, to go shopping, to take their children to the doctor, etc.

"Those cars could have been used for very needy working-class families," said Carolyn Hayden, a Glendarden, Md., transportation consultant. "It will go down in the annals as a missed opportunity."

More like a fantastically horrible idea. Think about it: $3 billion to essentially keep people unemployed. What's not to like about that?

The Keynesian gimmickry employed by the Obama administration to get us out of the recession were intended to be quick-hitters to boost the economy. What were finding, however, is that as short-lived as these programs were they have a legacy and a human cost that will be felt for years.

Tuesday, September 27, 2011

It's feeling like February 2009 all over again




Alternate headline: This is what we are getting for all those Ivy League degrees.


Everything you need to know about the folly of Keynesian gimmickry summed up in a few short paragraphs:

Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner didn't dispute a Harvard economist's estimate that each job in the White House's jobs plan would cost $200,000, but said the pricetag is the wrong way to measure the bill's worth.

And he also pointed out, in an interview today with ABC News' David Muir, that there is no other option on the table for getting the economy moving and putting more people back to work.

"You've got to think about the costs of the alternatives," Geithner said when asked about Harvard economist Martin Feldstein's calculation that each job created by President Obama's American Jobs Act would cost taxpayers about $200,000.

"If government does nothing, it does nothing now because they're scared by politics or they want to debate what's perfect, then there will be fewer Americans back to work, the economy will be weaker," he said.

"We can borrow money for 10 years as the government of the United States because people have confidence in this country at less than 2 percent," he said. "The responsible path now is to take advantage of the unique position we're in as a country. People have a lot of confidence in us. Let's take advantage of that now to do things that help growth in the short-term."

Well... we suppose one of the alternatives for this debt-racked country would be to not spend $200,000 per job on jobs that most certainly won't generate $200,000 salaries.

Then again, when you are part of a brain (and jobs!)trust that throws around figures like 1:1 and 1:1.84 as multiplier effects for government spending, you really aren't all that concerned with what jobs will cost, in fact, given the logic that's employed with respect to their presumed multiplier effects, why even appear apologetic for a mere 200 large? Why stop there? Is $300, 400... 500 thousand per job a problem, now?

And dig the assumption that the government must do something is the assumed creator of jobs and wealth in this country. Again, when you buy into the multiplier effect argument, this is your default position.

Please re-read that last paragraph from the article - we did, several times - because it makes zero sense. No, Tim, people don't trust you and that's part of the problem. You've been at this for well over two years now and selling the same crap that you pitched back in the initial stages of this administration. It didn't work then and it sure as hell isn't going to work now. It's all just a simple re-hash of this administration's triumphant "I won" campaign back in Jan/Feb 2009 when the $800 billion Porkulus jobs package was being pushed through.

What's changed? Not much. 2-1/2 years and only a few more trillion in debt combined with chronic un/under-employment and a stagnating economy.

Friday, August 26, 2011

Instavision, capitalism and morality

Glenn Reynolds sits down with John Allison, former CEO of BB&T, to discuss the causes of the financial crisis, what it is we are doing completely wrong to recover from it and the moral nature of capitalism.



Understanding what happened in the financial crisis is complex and people are looking for simple solutions; they're looking for solutions like "greed" which is not the cause of the financial crisis. In fact the Federal Reserve is the primary cause of the financial crisis - they printed too much money which resulted in a bubble which is really a massive mis-investment and it ended up in the residential real estate market because of government housing policy: affordable housing, sub-prime lending that was primarily financed by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

In fact, history (shows) that what we've done with government policy always fails. If you look at trying to correct corrections by spending money you don't have to do things that don't need to be done, which is what a stimulus program really is, and try to finance that spending by printing money, it always fails.


So, why do we keep doing it?

Unfortunately, Keynes theory which is the basis of the current actions has got a lot of academic credibility even though it's failed and that's because it gives Congress and the government lots of power; interestingly enough it gives academics lots of power. The answer is the government need not do anything... It's really just a huge power lust for politicians and academics.


There's almost an inverse relationship that you describe between the where the government is most involved, you have the worst consequences (financial sector) and where it's least involved, like (in) technology, you have the best outcomes.

If the Federal Reserve can manipulate the quantity and value of money it makes it very hard to make business decisions.


Capitalism as a "moral" system.

Capitalism is the only moral system, because it's the only system that is consistent with man's fundamental nature as an independent thinking being. And in order to think for yourself and be productive, you have to be free. And capitalism is the only system that allows people to be free to think and innovate and all human progress is based on creativity.







Monday, August 22, 2011

Smog, traffic, crime and graffiti and all that they have to show for it is their crappy newspaper




One in a series that takes a look at what's going on with the L.A. Times.



The President will not be unveiling his much-anticipated jobs plan until September but in the meantime, the Pulitzer prize-winning Los Angeles Times has weighed in on what they think will resuscitating our backsliding economy.

Here was a tease link on Times' web page last week:

Steve Lopez: Villaraigosa talks financial sense; now it's Brown's turn


Hmmm... Color us intrigued. Perhaps what Lopez was going to talk about was the mayor's willingness to put public employee benefits and pensions on the the table as a way to restore some fiscal order to the city and have that serve as the roadmap for similar action at the state level.

That hope, however, was short-lived... this is the L.A. Times we're talking about. So, what was the financial sense-talking that Lopez was referring to? Here goes:


He told me weeks ago that he was going to do it, and he did. L.A. Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa said Tuesday in a Sacramento speech that it’s time to test the voltage in some so-called third-rail issues, including Proposition 13.

He did not, however, go as far as he might have –- precisely because it’s a third-rail issue, particularly for homeowners. So instead he took the split-roll approach, arguing that commercial property owners who got the same tax protections from the landmark 1978 proposition as private homeowners need to pony up now.

Eh. So, let's get this straight: businesses and jobs are leaving this state for the more friendly environs of states like Utah, Arizona and Texas because of the onerous tax and regulatory burdens imposed by the state and Lopez wants to increase the cost of doing business here in California? Unreal.




Alright, let's see what the other genius on the Times' Op-ed staff, Michael Hiltzik, thinks needs to happen to revive economy. He's calling for "bold" initiatives. Cool. Bold. Kind of like thinking outside the box, perhaps? Bold, as in doing something that hasn't been tried before. Like not doing the same old things that have proven to be abject failures. That sort of bold?

Nope.

1. Fix housing...

Yet as I've written before, the administration's homeowner rescue efforts have been pathetic. As part of the $700-billion banking bailout of 2008, about $50 billion was supposed to be devoted to mortgage relief, including nearly $30 billion to the mortgage modification program known as HAMP. Of that sum, only about $2 billion had been spent as of June 30, according to the bailout program's inspector general. The government made sure that bailout money got to the banks, even some that didn't want it. But homeowners have gotten barely a taste.

That remaining HAMP money is part of an unspent balance of $53 billion in the bailout program that may still be available for disbursement, according to the inspector general, depending on how it's used. Obama may not need a further congressional vote to use it. His first order of business should be to dramatically restructure HAMP, say by taking the initiative for mortgage modifications away from the banks, which have done almost nothing but gum up the process. And then put that money to use.


2. Build! The $30-billion infrastructure bank, which resembles a bipartisan idea that has been kicking around Congress for too long (the co-sponsors are Sens. John Kerry [D-Mass.] and Kay Bailey Hutchison [R-Tex.]) is a start, but only a start. If the public-private partnerships Kerry and Hutchison foresee would really create a gain of more than $600 billion over 10 years for every $10 billion spent from the public till, as they suggest, why take a cheeseparing approach?

A $100-billion fund would create $6 trillion in value, and given the sorry state of the U.S. infrastructure, that would only scratch the surface of what's needed as an investment in future economic growth. Let's see Obama put a truly ambitious program on the table, and let's hear the Republicans in Congress explain why we don't need the work.



There you have it, ladies and gentlemen... Bold: More Keynesian gimmickry that has forestalled a true housing recovery by keeping bad risk mortages afloat. Bold: More Porkulus like the the $800 billion stimulus plan that was signed into law two and half years ago and which promised to keep unemployment under 8% and which, of course, did nothing of the sort except to prop up faltering state budgets and which also delayed serious discussion about what to do about those faltering budgets until only recently in states such as Wisconsin and New Jersey.

After reading those two pieces above, it begs the question regarding just what alternate universe the Times Op-ed board resides. There is simply a complete detachment from the facts-on-the-ground and a complete unwillingness to acknowledge failed policies.

Some newspaper, huh?


Tuesday, August 16, 2011

Paul Krugman: we need a cold war with space aliens or something

Yesterday, when we were musing about what sort of re-branding Team O was going to apply to their tired old bag of Keynesian stunts, little did we know that Paul Krugman was way out ahead of the curve with his messaging. How far out there? Like, way out there, man... way the freak out there.


Gird thyselves, people, against the gnarly Martians...





If we discovered that, you know, space aliens were planning to attack and we needed a massive buildup to counter the space alien threat and really inflation and budget deficits took secondary place to that, this slump would be over in 18 months. And then if we discovered, oops, we made a mistake, there aren’t any aliens, we’d be better–


Good grief. How bad are things when you are coming up with Twilight Zone episodes to justify horrible economic policies? So bad, we almost ignored Fareed Zakaria's patently ridiculous dig-a-hole/fill-a-hole multiplier effect theory.

And to what Krugman is saying, doesn't this administration manage by crisis as it is, space alien threat or not?

Yep. Don't expect anything different economic policy-wise from Team O, however, how it is that it will be justified should prove to be highly amusing.

Monday, August 15, 2011

News item of the day

News ledes that make you wonder upon which planet the New York Times and/or the Obama administration are currently residing.

As the economy worsens, President Obama and his senior aides are considering whether to adopt a more combative approach on economic issues, seeking to highlight substantive differences with Republicans in Congress and on the campaign trail rather than continuing to pursue elusive compromises, advisers to the president say.

Elusive compromises like Porkulus, Cash for Clunkers, Cash for Caulkers, car company takeovers and ObamaCare all which enjoyed zero bi-partisan support and which did nothing for, and can be argued, did further harm to the economy. Those elusive compormises?

Mr. Obama plans to spend time this weekend considering his options, advisers said. The White House expects to unveil new job-creation proposals in early September
.

Can't wait to see how the same old Keynesian gimmickry is going to be re-packaged and re-spun in just a few weeks.


So far, most signs point to a continuation of the nonconfrontational approach — better to do something than nothing — that has defined this administration. Mr. Obama and his aides are skeptical that voters will reward bold proposals if those ideas do not pass Congress. It is their judgment that moderate voters want tangible results rather than speeches.

“If you’re talking about a stunt, I don’t think a stunt is what the American people are looking for,” the White House press secretary, Jay Carney, told reporters on Wednesday. “They’re looking for leadership, and they’re looking for a focus on economic growth and job creation.”

Actually, give "nothing" a try. Seriously. Give it a whack because nothing they have tried so far has done any good. And stunts? Mr. Carney, kind sir, stunts and demand-side gimmicks are all this administration has offered up.


And as for our wondering about re-packaging failed Keynesian policies, it doesn't look like Team O is going to even worry about any slick re-branding because it's mainstream economic theory, dontcha know?

A wide range of economists say the administration should call for a new round of stimulus spending, as prescribed by mainstream economic theory, to create jobs and promote growth. It is clear that the House would never pass such a plan.


The campaign meme of the Obama adminstration which will be dutifully parroted by their water-carriers in the media has been set and you won't be surprised to know the crappy state of the economy has nothing to do with them but rather the fellow that preceded Obama and those damn pesky Republicans that keep getting in the way of allowing the administration from further ruining the economy.




Friday, July 8, 2011

Lessons (not) Learned




If some of the things you read here by us in this post sound a tad repititious, don't blame us but rather those who wish to keep repeating the same mistakes.


President Obama made a rare admission of a policy misstep Wednesday, acknowledging that his administration failed to provide enough support to struggling homeowners and recognize the scope of the nation’s housing crisis.

Despite predictions by Obama’s advisers that the housing market would rebound by now, real estate prices are falling once again. And the administration’s efforts to push banks to modify the mortgages of families who missed their monthly payments have been widely criticized as lacking.

Obama first raised the issue Wednesday when a questioner during a town hall event asked what mistakes the president had made in handling the economy.

“The continuing decline in the housing market is something that hasn’t bottomed out as quickly as we expected,” Obama responded.

Later, he added, that his administration’s efforts to help struggling homeowners were “not enough.”

“And so we’re going back to the drawing board,” he said.


Step away from the drawing board, please!


The administration's series of tax credits and home-owners' assistance programs is reminding us, in a sense, of Cash for Clunkers in that one of its "accomplishments" was that it merely stole demand from the future, propping up housing prices in the short term only to see them fall again once those programs expired.

Instead of allowing the market to take its course and wring the bad actors out of the system, they insist on employing one round of Keynesian gimmickry after another, prolonging the agony, promoting market uncertainty and forestalling what would be any real and natural housing recovery.

As it stands, however, the President shows his colors as a true believer in that the statist solution for failed statist policies is simply more statism.

Sunday, June 12, 2011

Wait, what?

One in a series that takes a look at the bizarre, the absurd and certainly the unexpeceted.


In the news a couple of day ago:

Still, through eight months of the 2011 fiscal year the nation is facing its third straight $1 trillion-plus deficit -- totaling $927.4 billion so far compared with $935.6 billion during the same period in 2010, about $8 billion less, according to the report.

Vice President Joseph Biden and congressional leaders will meet several times next week to discuss a way to tackle the burdensome debt and increase the $14.3 trillion debt limit before Aug. 2, when the Treasury says the U.S will default.


And the solution for this would be...

Senior Senate Democrats are growing frustrated by what they see as President Obama’s passivity on the economy, and are beginning to discuss a large infrastructure package funded by tax increases.

Some Democrats, such as Iowa Sen. Tom Harkin, who serves as chairman of the Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee, think such a package could lower the unemployment rate by as much as two percentage points.

“I am concerned about the Obama administration’s approach on this,” Harkin said. “It always has been about jobs. I think the administration kind of got snookered talking about the deficit and the debt after the last election.

“The last election was about jobs and the economy, and now we’re in a position where we really do need some economic pump-priming by the federal government,” he said.

Sen. Jay Rockefeller (D-W.Va.), chairman of the Senate Commerce Committee, endorsed Harkin’s argument for more infrastructure spending, and said it is gaining support in the broader caucus.

“There’s very broad support,” Rockefeller said. “There’s no other way to get at this problem.”
(italics, ours)


Wait, what?




We may be losing it a bit in our advanced age, but didn't we just do some stimulus, some federal government pump-priming 2 years ago? And didn't "they" tell us that the $787 billion stimulus package that was passed in February of 2009 wouldn't let unemployment rise above 8%? Didn't they? Why, yes... yes, they did.

You all remember this graph, dontcha?




At the link, The Hill, doesn't even bother to point out the screaming obvious: we've been down this road before and congressional Democrats either want everyone to forget Porkulus or are such single-track dogmatists that they cannot conceive of any other solutions than Piled-Hire-and-Deeper government activism.


Lazy-ass journalism and zombified politicians who would rather us not pay any attention: not a good combination.





P.S. We may need to drop "unexpected" from our tag line at the top of the post.

Wednesday, June 8, 2011

Strange musings




The President had some curious things to say regarding the economy at a joint presser with Germany's Chancellor Angela Merkel yesterday.

“It is just very important for folks to remember how close we came to complete disaster,” he told the watching TV cameras and reporters.

“The world economy took a severe blow two and a half years ago, and in part that is because of a whole set of policy decisions that had been made, and challenges that have been unaddressed over the course of the previous decade,” he said, standing alongside Merkel, whose economy has rebounded during the last two years.
(italics, ours... you know, just sayin')


That ungracious and ungrateful so-and-so. If Bailout Nation was initiated under Bush and then put on human growth hormones under Obama, why doesn't the Prez give any props to Bush for getting the wheels up?


And then there was this:

“Two years ago… we were still near the bottom of a vicious recession… we could have done what a lot of folks in Washington thought we should do, and that is nothing” amid extensive passages promising investment and government support for communities, he declared.
(italics, ours)

Oh, no we didn't. We all knew Team O was going to do something... quite a lot of something as a matter of fact.

And about that nothing. Know who actually recommended doing nothing? Christina Romer, that's who. Well, to be completely fair to Ms. Romer, former administration economic advisor who bailed out a few months back to go teach at Cal Berkeley, she was an advocate for doing something, chiefly the $787 billion stimulus package known affectionately in these parts as Porkulus. However, her prediction for doing nothing would turn out to be much better for employment figures had we done that instead of doing something as the chart below shows.





And how did the President respond to all the bad economic news that rolled in last week?

“Economic data that in better times would pass without comment, now suddenly people wonder well are we going to go back to this terrible crisis and all that affects consumer confidence; it affects business confidence; it affects the federal markets,” he said.

Don't know about you all but we can't recall a 9.1% unemployment rate passing without comment. Perhaps this is what explains him dating his signage of the Westminster Abbey guest registry "May 2008"... retreating to a happier time and place when no one in the media ever questioned, poked or prodded with respect to his policy positions or past associations.

Expect more disassociations from reality from the President if things don't unexpectedly turn around here, right quick.

Monday, June 6, 2011

More on our (most) recent housing woes

From the Cato Institute
:


House prices were always going to find their “true” bottom. The question was simply: did we want to get there right away, or drag out the process? Washington chose the course of dragging out the process, at considerable cost. I believe dragging out the process has only further spooked potential buyers. Any buyer today has to suspect that further price declines are possible. We need to get to the point where the only direction is up. We aren’t there yet. Policymakers continue to ignore the basics of supply and demand. Unfortunately the rest of us pay the price for their doing so.

Yep


We'll all be hearing a lot over the next 17-18 months or so regarding the bold and daring steps the administration took to rescue the economy through gimmickry such as the GM and Chrysler bailouts and home-owners assistance programs and how it was the politically-unpopular thing to do. Nonsense. What's so bold and daring about spending tax-payer money?

As the housing market is proving, sometimes the bold and daring thing to do is to do absolutely nothing. And many times doing absolutley nothing is indeed politically-unpopular but totally necessary.

Sunday, June 5, 2011

Groundhog Day: June 5



Good lord, here we go again.

Yet another news item that could've been written at any time during the past 2 or 3 years.




The Obama administration wants to help more struggling Americans stay in their homes by reducing the amount they owe on their troubled mortgages, a top Treasury official said Saturday.

"We are very definitely trying to facilitate more principal reductions," said Timothy Massad, Treasury's acting assistant secretary for financial stability. "It is a very important piece of the overall solution," he said.

The administration is trying through taxpayer-funded programs to prevent homeowners from losing their homes. Nearly $50 billion has been set aside from the $700 billion bank bailout known as the Troubled Asset Relief Program, or TARP, to help distressed homeowners.

Persistently high unemployment and a weak housing market pose a threat to President Obama's re-election prospects next year.

So far, one of the programs has helped some 670,000 distressed homeowners win lower mortgage payments. But that has done very little to help the overall housing market, which remains depressed even as other parts of the economy have started to recover.

(ed. note: And these parts would be..?)


A glut of houses for sale, foreclosures, tight credit and little demand have impeded the housing recovery. Recent data showed that home prices dropped below the low seen in April 2009 during the financial crisis.
(italics, ours)


It has yet to dawn upon the economic illiterates of this administration that all they are doing is prolonging the agony of this recession. To no avail. And the best part is that they are using your tax-dollars to do it. That's right: a pending double-dip recession paid for with your money.


One housing counselor expressed frustration with the servicers, saying more people would still be in their homes if their principal was reduced.

"Servicers are not required to do it," said Shaneece Hudson, a mortgage adviser with the National Community Reinvestment Coalition. "Principal reduction is an option (for the servicers.) But they don't do it. They will do everything else first," she said.

Crazy, we know, that servicers would not want to lose money in a voluntarily-entered contract with the home-buyer.

"There is no silver bullet. But I think there are a lot of programs out there that are providing help to people," said Massad. "If anyone has specific ideas that haven't been tried, I am happy to hear about them."
How about doing nothing? Really. Quit pouring billions of dollars into a zombified housing market so a true recovery can start taking place.


If the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and getting the same results then check out why B-Daddy thinks the President ought to get his money back from Harvard and Columbia.

Saturday, June 4, 2011

The most totally expeceted news item lede of the day

There... they go again...


WASHINGTON (Reuters) - U.S. employers hired far fewer workers than expected in May and the jobless rate rose to 9.1 percent, raising concerns the economy might be stuck in a painful slow-growth mode.


Two things: 1) Why is this sort of news so continually and habitually unexpected?
Shameless cheerleading or complete incompetence? This lede could've been written at pretty much any time over the past two years or so.

The question needs to be asked because 2) precisely what actions have been taken by the administration with respect to the economy and/or what has transpired that would lead economists to react so unexpectedly?


O.K., one more: 3) Doesn't the last line pretty much say, "uh, yeah, deal with it, chumps"?



We need new economists. Keynesian hacks and tongue-bathers need not apply.

Thursday, June 2, 2011

Won't get fooled again: Redux

Consider this a companion piece to yesterday's post regarding the amnesia suffered by the New York Times editorial board regarding what it will take to recover from the Great Recession which was essentially a call for more Keynesian tomfoolery. It would appear that Times columnist Paul Krugman was the ghost writer for that piece as the following is the money paragraph from his latest column:

For example, we could have W.P.A.-type programs putting the unemployed to work doing useful things like repairing roads — which would also, by raising incomes, make it easier for households to pay down debt. We could have a serious program of mortgage modification, reducing the debts of troubled homeowners. We could try to get inflation back up to the 4 percent rate that prevailed during Ronald Reagan’s second term, which would help to reduce the real burden of debt.

Always cracks us up that progressives look back to the Great Depression as the good ol' days. Stands to reason, though, as dependency upon government programs was at an all-time high and is looked upon today as the panacea for all that ails us. Funny... we thought that $800 billion stimulus package passed in the initial stages of this administration and that is now conveniently slipping down the memory hole was supposed to kick-start the economy and keep unemployment under 8 percent.

And still with the mortgage modification programs. Taking your money to prop up bad risks hasn't been working out so hot lately as front page headlines in papers across the country will attest.

And who isn't up for paying more to put food on the table? What might be for economists like Krugman isn't going to cut it for working families dealing with real world issues and isn't going to make the reality of the debt burden magically disappear.


Again, it's as if the past 2 or 3 years never happened such is the manner of reasoning and logic currently being applied to this slump which is only entrenching us further and prolonging the agony.

What some would have us forget, others still have been paying attention.

Wednesday, June 1, 2011

New York Times: Won't get fooled again




Michael Barone notes just how unexpected more bad economic news always seems to economists and Big Media as a whole.

Unexpectedly!

As megablogger Glenn Reynolds, aka Instapundit, has noted with amusement, the word “unexpectedly,” or variants thereof, keeps cropping up in mainstream-media stories about the economy.

“New U.S. claims for unemployment benefits unexpectedly climbed,” reported cnbc.com May 25.

“Personal consumption fell,” Business Insider reported the same day, “when it was expected to rise.”

“Durable goods declined 3.6 percent last month,” Reuters reported May 25, “worse than economists’ expectations.”

“Previously owned home sales unexpectedly fall,” headlined Bloomberg News May 19.

“U.S. home construction fell unexpectedly in April,” wrote the Wall Street Journal May 18.

Those examples are all from the last two weeks. Reynolds has been linking to similar items since October 2009.

So, what gives? Are the economists and econ beat writers a) hopeless cheerleaders for the President who will go to any lengths to give him cover or b) do they really believe the Keynesian gimmickry employed by Team O will work this time around or c) are they just abjectly terrible at what they do?

Since the 3 are definetely not exclusive to one another, we'd go with a combination of all 3 by varying degrees depending upon the individual or media outlet.



And right on cue, here's the New York Time's lead editorial from Tuesday's paper:

A month ago, when an initial gauge of first-quarter economic growth came in surprisingly weak, many policy makers and economists expected the bad news to prove fleeting. But when revised data were released last week, the growth estimate remained stuck at an annual rate of 1.8 percent, compared with 3.1 percent at the end of last year.

More troubling in the latest figures, consumer spending — the largest component of the economy — was especially slow. Stagnant wages and higher prices for gas and food are squeezing family budgets, while falling home equity hurts consumer confidence. That suggests more bad news to come.

OK, then - they've gone on record as stating that when more bad news rolls down the pike, it certainly won't be unexpected.

And America's paper of record should know well enough because they are advocating for much of the same statist Keynesian hocus pocus that has been tried already. After bashing the Republicans, here are the big ideas championed by the Old Gray Lady:

The White House has offered sounder ideas, including job retraining, plans to boost educational achievement and tax increases to help cover needed spending.
(ed. note: Can someone please give us a precise operational definition of "retraining"?)


The sinkholes in the economy should be obvious. Most prominently, the housing market is still awful, and state and local government budgets are still a mess. Conditions apparently have to get worse before deficit-obsessed policy makers will be ready to address them, including with bolstered foreclosure relief and more fiscal aid to states. More delay would only imperil the recovery, such as it is. And without a strong recovery, it will be even harder to repair the budget. Continued hard times means low tax revenues and high safety-net spending.

The administration could work to ease the rules for refinancing mortgages owned by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the government-run mortgage giants. Easier refinancings would lower monthly payments for potentially hundreds of thousands of borrowers in good standing, and in that way, free up spending money to boost the economy.
(italics, ours)


Unreal...


It's like the Times editorial board had just awoken from a near 2-1/2 year slumber and thought that the crap that either landed us in this mess in the first place or had been prolonging the agony represented bold and fresh thinking. Do they not read what they print before going to the presses?


So, yeah... not forcing states to deal with their own self-made fiscal messes, taking your hard-earned scratch to string along poor-risk home-owners so that Fannie and Freddie represent a giant national mortgage methadone clinic, soaking the rich who will merely alter their behavior to avoid these taxes (happens every time, folks) and, you know, retraining, are all the big ideas put forth from the economically illiterate Rip Van Winkles at the Times.

At least they won't be caught off guard when their terrible ideas produce the very results they themselves are expecting.

H/T: Roger Hedgecock