Monday, April 7, 2008

75th Anniversary of...

the re-write to the Volstead Act, better known as the "The Day the Beer Flowed Again." B-Daddy here, commemorating what must be a high holy day for a blog site named Beers with Demo. Prohibition, a result of the 18th Amendment to the Constitution, was still in effect on April 7, 1933. But the 18th amendment had not defined the term "intoxicating liquors." Congress had passed the Volstead Act in October 1919, defining intoxicating beverages at greater than 0.5% alcohol. Fast forward to 1933 and the country is in a depression, prohibition is widely flaunted and FDR had won election to the Presidency promising a repeal of prohibition. Still, a constitutional amendment takes time to repeal, so the quick fix to get brewery workers back on the job and create a market for grain farmers, was to change the definition of intoxicating beverage to greater than 3.2% alcohol, the traditional value for beer of the era. Very quickly the states ratified the 21st Amendment, ending prohibition in most of the country. The mood of the country is captured here:



Of course, B-Daddy has some lessons learned.

Repealing prohibition turned alcohol from a drain on the Treasury to a source of revenue. Anything else we prohibit that might have a similarly beneficial effect?

Prohibition was based on the notion that we could legislate human goodness. We cannot.

Badly written law undermines the entire concept of the rule of law, because of widespread disobedience.

Prohibition sets the stage for corruption.

Prohibition and gun control both seek to solve complex societal ills by banning inanimate objects. This approach seldom works.

Beer is good.


















H/T: LA Times by way of realclearpolitics.

6 comments:

Foxfier said...

Prohibition also failed because alcohol is a rather, um, traditional thing. (is there a single culture that DIDN'T find a way to get drunk?)

Dean said...

B-Daddy, thank you for this excellent and relevant post. After watching the John Adams mini on HBO last night and then reading you post, I was reminded of what Ben Franklin said: "Beer is God's proof that he loves us".

Anonymous said...

Is that Robin Williams just before his "Mork" days hoisting that pint?

- Mongo

Anonymous said...

Hey, wait a second...

I didn't think anybody in the BwD circle was allowed to read the L.A. Times for fear of getting Liberal Juice all over themselves? Wasn't there some sort of BwD self-imposed denial akin to banning Shakespeare in red-state schools? What's with the link?

I may have to report this as a violation to the CPAC.

- Mongo the Worldy & Well-Read

B-Daddy said...

Mongo,
For beer related topics we make an exception to our usual hidebound ideologically based rules. Even though it presents us with painful cognitive dissonance (because we conservatives are not as intellectually-abled as you liberals) beer is a topic for which exceptions can always be made.

Dean said...

Mongo said "Liberal Juice".

...picture is of the father of proprietor of Avocado Dreams, which I link to in the right-hand margin.