Tuesday, January 18, 2011

This would explain a few things

Maybe reading the Constitution to open the 112th Congress wasn't such a bad idea after all.

First, the bad news: Americans given a basic Constitution/American civics quiz by the Intercollegiate Studies Institute failed miserably.

And now, even worse news: as bad as the general public performed on the quiz, elected officials fared even worse.

For five years now, the Intercollegiate Studies Institute has been conducting a national survey to gauge the quality of civic education in the country. We've surveyed more than 30,000 Americans, most of them college students, but also a random sample of adults from all educational and demographic backgrounds.

Included in the adult sample was a small subset of Americans (165 in all) who, when asked, identified themselves as having been "successfully elected to government office at least once in their life" -- which can include federal, state or local offices.

But those elected officials who took the test scored an average 5 percentage points lower than the national average (49 percent vs. 54 percent), with ordinary citizens outscoring these elected officials on each constitutional question. Examples:

•Only 49 percent of elected officials could name all three branches of government, compared with 50 percent of the general public.
•Only 46 percent knew that Congress, not the president, has the power to declare war -- 54 percent of the general public knows that.
•Just 15 percent answered correctly that the phrase "wall of separation" appears in Thomas Jefferson's letters -- not in the U.S. Constitution -- compared with 19 percent of the general public.
•And only 57 percent of those who've held elective office know what the Electoral College does, while 66 percent of the public got that answer right. (Of elected officials, 20 percent thought the Electoral College was a school for "training those aspiring for higher political office.")

Words cannot describe how horiffic these results are. We can almost understand the failing grades of the unwashed masses given the state of our education system but for the political class who felt the call of public office to perform this poorly is downright frightening.

Full disclosure: we felt comfortable running that smack after taking the quiz ourselves.

So, whaddya say, gang? Want to take a crack at it? The 33 question quiz can be found here.

We scored 31 out of 33. We botched the Lincoln/Douglas debate question and a question later on about taxes where we just got lazy. Too bad. Two wrong is two wrong.

Let us know how you did.

Exit question: Was there an explicit limited government/free market slant to the questioning in the quiz?

Exit cheap shots: Wonder how our old friend Phil Hare, the Illinois Democrat who was voted out of office this past November, would fare on the quiz?

Maybe that was a little to "uncivil" for you. Perhaps our friend Pete Stark (D-CA) would do a little better.


Ohioan@Heart said...

32 of 33. (The score came out 33 of 33, but I'll admit that I would have been guessing on the Jefferson letters question with out the leading info from your blog, so I corrected for that.)

Yes, I thought the bias was there.

Mutnodjmet said...

32 out of 33 -- but I disagree that increasing spending during a recession is prudent, so I give myself 100% :)

But I am a Democrat, so it is OK for me to change the rules for a better outcome. :)

Road Dawg said...

I wonder how this congressman would fare:


Probably less than Miss Guam!

Shameful 27 for the Dawg

Dean said...

O@H, I'll take that as a compliment.

Leslie, I tend to agree but I think the thought was "the Keynesian knee-jerk reaction usually taken by governments when faced with a recession."

And, yes, your party affiliation totally absolves you of any grade inflation.

'Dawg, no shame necessary. A 27 would still put you in the top 5th percentile, I'm imagining.

Great work, everyone. Let's keep it rolling.

Harrison said...

They actually missed a few sections because, I'm not making this up, the pages were STUCK TOGETHER.

B-Daddy said...

31/33 for me, thought the economic specialization question was not straightforward.
I'm glad to see that elected officials scored close to 50% on some key issues, it seems likely that they might remind their fellow travelers of the correct answer in time of crisis.

Secular Apostate said...

I got 31 out of 33. I missed the Gettysburg Address question (shame on me!) and #33 about government revenue. Debt and Deficit both start with a "d" so I think #33 was a trick question and I'm going to award myself 3 points. That makes it 34 out of 33 correct. You can mail my Franklin Mint Gold Star at your convenience.

Nice quiz, though. I enjoyed it. Thanks for bringing it to my attention.

SarahB said...

not surprised in the LEAST

SEO Manchester said...

Nice post having excellent contents.I have been searching for this type of posts. I wanted to thank you for this excellent read!! I definitely loved every little bit of it.